BEHIND THE SCENES
Last weekend I met in Paris for dinner one of my old friends that I havent seen in years. (I am french, and he is too). During the discussion, we came to talk F1. I learnt that he became a die hard F1-fan in the last 3 years. But most importantly, and you wont believe this : this person is one of Nicolas Todt best friends. (Nicolas Todt is the son of Jean and a manager of Felipe Massa)
Needless to say we stayed awake until 3 am, me mainly asking questions from him. And he telling me all he had talked about on various occasions with his friend Nicolas Todt.
And I learnt a lot of interesting things - I was so excited and I still am, that I would better only write here the facts without going too much in the details because if not this will be a 10 pages post - I will go in depth later on - I have still to cool down a little bit, because talking to him was like reading a Ferrari-insider magazine of 100 pages at once.
(the source of all this info is Nicolas Todt).
The 2005 seat change in the number 2 driver position at Ferrari :
- Todt already considered replacing Rubens (despite good results) at the end of the 2004 season, because he thought it was time to "refresh". For reasons I will develope later, it wasnt done. Rubens, during the winter testings (before the begin of season) reportedly "didnt behave and contribute as Ferrari would have expected", and as he had contributed in the previous years. According to Nicolas, Todt from that day on said to his son : "RB seems tired, and I can understand this. We need some refreshment. But as he contributed to our success so much in the last 5 years, I will leave to him the decision to honour or not to honour his contract until the end. But a renewal is out of the question." From this day on, Ferrari accelerated some contacts, with some drivers which are already established F1 drivers and some which are not (Luizzi for exemple).
The 1st half of the season 2005 convinced Todt more and more that RB should and must leave. On that MS move on RB a few months ago, that RB looked so upset about, Todt got quite angry at Rubens and privatelly summoned him in his office. Nicolas Todt said that the criticism of RB towards MS (who Todt both considers as the best driver in the world and a very close friend) did upset Todt a lot and that he got very angry at RB from this day on. One week later, Todt told RB he was "free to leave if unhappy at Ferrari".
From that date on, only details (financial and legal) were fixed but decision to dump RB was already taken and approved by LucaDI since several months.
Luca DI only advised Todt not to make it known yet internly to the mechanics and engineers of RB.
Where will RB go ?
To B.A.R.
But he had advanced contact with Toyota, as Trulli is also in contact with BAR. that would have been: RB --> Toyota alongside another Schumacher / Trulli to BAR with Button.
Who are those mysterious drivers in that so called "Ferrari driver wish-list" that Todt sometimes hints at during interviews ?
- The so called top-of-the list driver that Todt always hints about (mainly since beginning of 2005), without telling the name, is Räikkönen.
Räikkönen is on top of that secret Ferrari wish-list since YEARS and it hasnt changed.
- Alonso and Button are also on that list but Todt considers them both lower.
- Interestingly, Ferrari is keeping a very interested eye on a couple of young very talented drivers who are not in F1 yet, but that Ferrari plans to send to Minardi or Red Bull in the next 2 years. Those drivers are not famous or necessarelly those that win the championships. So dont search the ones which are full of titles. Ferrari apparently considers some drivers who arrive 2nd or third as more talented.
- Montoya is not even in that list.
- Fisichella will never ever drive for Ferrari. Until JT and/or Luca Di are in charge at least, as they are both strongly against an italian driver at Ferrari, for political reasons mainly.
Why Massa / Why now ?
Todt always considered Massa very fast and talented. Some years ago, during a 2 week intensive session at Maranello, Ferrari assessed the technical aptitudes of Massa, along with other drivers, for a test driver position. Schumacher was there and had his word to say about the test driver.
He chose Massa from the rest. Todt did the same.
During the first months of his position as a Ferrari test driver, Massa was closely under the watch of Michael Schumacher. Nicolas Todt says that the persons who, since Todt arrived at Ferrari decide who gets the test driver position is not Todt himself or any guy of the management. Schumacher himself decides and has the final word. Badoer is the only person consulted in this matter. Todt has blind faith in the judgement of Schumacher and Badoer, preciselly for the evaluation of test-driver capabilities, and he leaves the decision to them. He then consults them and always apply their recommendations and choices. Burti was the same thing. Schumacher chose him, and Schumacher noticed he was a good development driver mostly because Alain Prost during a GP has hinted to Schumacher that Burti was a very capable developer. Schumacher and Prost are in good terms and takl frequently together, and Schumacher hold Prost (as everybody in F1) as the "reference" in terms of car develpment and technical abilities fo a driver.
Schumacher then proposed to Todt to test Burti. Only then could he assess if the guy was a capable developer. Once again Prost was not wrong.
And he was chosen.
Anyway back to Massa. During the first months of his testing appointment, Massa was under close scrutiny by Schumacher. THis was done on purpose as Todt was eager to find new talented blood but also technically able young driver. You can check the archives and see that Schumacher was very frequently at Maranello (testing or otherwise) when Massa was scheduled to test. Not only to keep a close eye on him but also to show him tricks and the methodology on car developement.
Very soon after his testing position began, Todt (advised by Schumacher) decided that Massa would be a long term Ferrari investment. his son Nicolas became very involved (management, etc...), Schumacher and Badoer were both summoned to show the kind all they knew about car development and tricks and tips. A meeting once took place with Todt, his son, and Badoer, where JT sent that "there should from now on be no technical secrets between you and Massa. Pass on all your knowledge - I told michael the same."
But Nicolas Todt says that although Massa is almost assured to be in the Ferrari-galaxy for the rest of his F1 career, his fathers preference for the DRIVER NUMBER ONE position still is, and by far, Räikkönen.
Massa will at most be the official and stable number 2 driver, and if he is not good enough, will stay test driver. But Todt eyes more Räikkönen for the day Schumacher retires.
Why is Montoya not in the Ferrari list of favourites
3 reasons:
1: Schumacher thinks he is a poorly able driver when it comes to technical knowledge and car development. And according to him this will never change.
Schumacher reportedly said once to Todt that "Montoya will never be a good car developer because his brain works not in the way rigourous car development demands, and he is too old to change this now". Schumacher went on saying that his brother Ralf also thought the same (while continually working with Montoya at Williams). From then on Todt convinced Luca DI (who was initially a Montoya fan) that Montoya was not a good choice for Ferrari, although a very talented driver.
2: He is not considered a stable character, and TOdt mainly wants stability - Nicholas Todt said that his father is impressed by many drivers, but that for a Ferrari-position, he doesnt even look at drivers which cannot stay and do the job for less than 3 years. Montoya is too influencable according to Todt (and so he thinks of his manager) and can be easily be lured away by any team - Whereas he is seeking only FOCUSED drivers for Ferrari.
Todt stronlgy believes in Cultural influence in this matter of focuseness (according to his son) - he has a big preference for Germans, and Northern people. He thinks (and his not necessarelly wrong here) they are more focused and stable, and do less "useless noise" than the others.
Thus his preference for Räikkönen over the rest.
Barrichello and Massa are exceptions for Todt.
WHile he always thought of Barrichello as a very able and focused developer, stable, etc... He didnt think of the same of Massa at the beginning.
Schumacher made him think otherwise and he noticed later on that this fierce kid on the track is also a very focused person, and humble on top of that.